Charles Kenyon: Where charity law and church law collide

Our columnist was shocked by an 'outdated' piece of legislation

Charles Kenyon
Charles Kenyon

It was a shock to find that a local charity is subject to ecclesiastical law as well a charity law. Under the 1806 Enclosure Act, some land was given to our church. In 1974 a registered charity was formed to administer it to the benefit of the church.

Recently a 25-year lease was agreed with a neighbour to rent the land. An order was obtained from the Charity Commission, which makes helpful provision for small charities that need to lease or sell property.

Our problem came from the Land Registry. The trustees of the charity were no longer proprietors: the owner was listed, from 2005, as the local diocese. The diocese pointed to the 1964 Incumbents and Churchwardens (Trusts) Measure of the Church of England, giving it the right to act as custodian trustees, having conducted a transfer with the parish in 1991. Custodian trustees are not listed in Charity Commission records. They must assist the managing trustees without regulating their legal actions, but the apparent primacy of ecclesiastical law imposes the diocese's retained solicitor, who, in this case, requires payment to incorporate the interests of the diocese into a simple lease.

Guidance from the Charity Commission, Custodian Trustees, appears to have been due for review since 2012. It is time to take control of this outdated legislation and stop thousands of small charities operating in the shadow of an expensive bureaucracy that their founders could never have envisaged.

Charles Kenyon lives near Market Rasen, retiredcolonel@oldvicarage.net

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register
Already registered?
Sign in

Before commenting please read our rules for commenting on articles.

If you see a comment you find offensive, you can flag it as inappropriate. In the top right-hand corner of an individual comment, you will see 'flag as inappropriate'. Clicking this prompts us to review the comment. For further information see our rules for commenting on articles.

comments powered by Disqus

More from Fundraising Week 2016…

Investec crowned Business of the Year at Business Charity Awards

Investec crowned Business of the Year at Business Charity Awards

The financial services firm was rewarded at a black-tie dinner in London last night for its work with the Bromley by Bow Centre in east London, one of 23 awards in total

Fundraising Week: Charities have been treated leniently, says Information Commissioner's Office

Fundraising Week: Charities have been treated leniently, says Information Commissioner's Office

Richard Marbrow, group manager for compliance at the ICO, tells a Fundraising Week event that investigating charities had been 'uncomfortable', but a zero had been taken off every fine

Fundraising Week: Day Three Highlights

Fundraising Week: Day Three Highlights

Review of the final day of the Fundraising Week conference, which focused on digital and data protection

Fundraising Week: Understanding how donors feel 'will be next big thing', says academic

Fundraising Week: Understanding how donors feel 'will be next big thing', says academic

Adrian Sargeant tells a Fundraising Week conference that charities should focus on building a connection with donors, and money will follow

Fundraising Week: A third of eligible charities have not yet paid levy, says Lord Grade

Fundraising Week: A third of eligible charities have not yet paid levy, says Lord Grade

The chair of the Fundraising Regulator tells Third Sector's Fundraising Week conference that 600 of the 1,900 charities asked to contribute to its costs have not paid so far

Fundraising Week: Day Two Highlights

Fundraising Week: Day Two Highlights

We take a look back at the second day of Fundraising Week, which focused on corporates, major donors and foundations

Fundraising Week: Regulation, lack of trust and rising costs 'will kill off some traditional fundraising'

Fundraising Week: Regulation, lack of trust and rising costs 'will kill off some traditional fundraising'

Marcus Missen, director of communications and fundraising at WaterAid, tells conference that his charity is becoming less concerned with making the ask and more with creating interest

Fundraising Week: Make your applications clearer, grant-seekers urged

Fundraising Week: Make your applications clearer, grant-seekers urged

Representatives of four major trusts and foundations tell a panel session that charities should have a better understanding of what funders are looking for

Watch: Big Questions Live highlights

Watch: Big Questions Live highlights

Leading figures from the charity and digital sectors debate the hottest topics in fundraising at Fundraising Week 2017

Fundraising Week: Basic compliance 'not enough to attract major donors', says academic

Fundraising Week: Basic compliance 'not enough to attract major donors', says academic

Beth Breeze, director of the Centre for Philanthropy, tells a Fundraising Week event that charities confuse 'hygiene' factors such as filing accounts on time with qualities that motivate donors