Church Commissioners paid investment director £515k last year

The Church of England's charity defends its salary policy after its latest annual report reveals that Tom Joy was paid a wage of £264,000 and a bonus of £251,000 in 2017

The annual report
The annual report

The Church of England's charity has defended its salary policy after paying its investment director more than £500,000 last year.

The Church Commissioners for England's 2017 annual report, which was published this week, revealed that Tom Joy received a salary of £264,000 and a bonus of £251,000, bringing his total pay packet to £515,000.

Joy received £461,000 overall in 2016, the accounts show.

They also show that nine asset managers shared a total of £986,000 in 2017.

Joy's bonus came despite the charity failing to hit its target of a 9.1 per cent total return on investments. It achieved 7.1 per cent.

Investable assets, however, grew from £7.9bn to £8.3bn.

The charity’s overall income grew from £159.6m in 2016 to £167.3m last year, the accounts show.

Joy's salary would rank him fifth in a list of the charity sector's biggest earners.

According to Third Sector's Charity Pay Study 2017, which was based on analysis of the accounts of the 150 largest charities by income in England and Wales, the Wellcome Trust topped the league with its highest-paid earner taking home just over £3m.

The Church Commissioners for England's large bonuses were paid despite Justin Welby, the Archbishop of Canterbury, urging companies to show pay restraint.

The charity also used its latest annual report to highlight how it uses its votes at company AGMs and meetings to prevent excessive pay elsewhere.

The report says: "The Commissioners and Pensions Board vote in over 2,500 company meetings each year.

"In 2017, we voted against 50 per cent of remuneration packages in the UK."

But a Church Commissioners for England spokeswoman said its remuneration policy was "entirely consistent" with its approach to other companies.

She said: "The payment is largely made up of long-term incentive payments that are assessed over a five-year period.

"These payments are paid out on the sixth year at 75 per cent and the remaining 25 per cent over the next two years.

"The increase is therefore to do with past performance, not this year’s.

"This policy is entirely consistent with our remuneration policy regarding other companies."

The report says investment managers "sit outside" the charity's general pay arrangements.

"The Church Commissioners are a large and sophisticated institutional investor and, as such, seek to attract and retain high calibre investment professionals," the report says.

"Accordingly, salaries are designed to reflect the market for investment specialists."

A remuneration committee, comprising trustees on the assets committee supported by independent benchmarking data, sets the LTIP.

LTIPs and high pay have caused controversy in the voluntary sector in recent years.

The Consumers' Association, the charity behind the consumer rights charity Which?, announced last year that it would discontinue its LTIP this year amid controversy over the size of awards.

Peter Vicary-Smith, chief executive of Which?, whose £462,000 pay packet drew criticism, announced this month that he would step down in September.

In February, the disability car charity Motability was criticised after a connected company, Motability Operations Group, was found to have paid its chief executive £1.7m in the year to 30 September 2017, including a long-term incentive scheme payment of almost £727,000.

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Already registered?
Sign in