Each received three-year sentences at Liverpool Crown Court last week for their part in the scam, which involved the family-run Aleef garages and newsagents chain, as well as the society, which was established by the brothers’ father Ahmed Patel in 1991 to advance Islam, promote race relations and advance education and leisure in the Bolton area.
A number of the garages and shops had two tills, but declared the takings from only one of them. The money from the other was paid into accounts under the name of Ahmed Patel and Great Lever Muslim Society, which the family also ran.
The charity’s bank accounts showed that more than £2.5m had been deposited between 1998 and 2002. However, its accounts filed with the Charity Commission for the same period record annual incomes of just less than £10,000. The rest of the money was used to fund the Patel family’s lifestyle.
The three brothers have stood down from the charity’s board, but their father, Ahmed Patel – who was deemed too ill to face charges – and another brother, Ibrahim, are still listed as trustees.
A statement from the commission confirmed that it was in contact with the remaining trustees “to ensure that the charity is administered properly going forward”.
It read: “The commission has monitored the risks to the charity and has been satisfied that its property and other interests have been protected so far as is practicable, balancing these interests with the need for the proper administration of justice.”
In addition to their jail sentences, the three Patel brothers were ordered to pay back the £5m and pay £500,000 costs, and they were banned from being company directors for 10 years. Another five people involved in the fraud were given custodial sentences and a further two were given community service.