Fundraising Week: RSPCA approach to campaigning 'mistaken', says head of communications Chris Wainwright

During a panel discussion, he says charities should be prepared to own up to problems and fix them, rather than blame the agendas of others

The RSPCA made a mistake in its approach to campaigning in the past, using sensationalist tactics that were inviting criticism, according to its head of communications.

But Chris Wainwright said more charities should be prepared to own up and attempt to fix the problem when they make mistakes, rather than claiming there was an agenda behind negative news stories.

Wainwright, who became director of communications and external affairs at the charity in January, made the comments during a panel discussion on public trust and the media at Third Sector’s Fundraising Week yesterday.

"Frankly, in my view the RSPCA got it wrong two years ago when it talked about the issues in relation to foxhunting and the badger cull," he said.

"The motive was right, the message was right, but the delivery and the execution were so sensationalist it was asking for a punch-up. That’s not what our supporters give us the money for; they give us the money to be the voice for our cause and to do the right things."

Wainwright said charities were in denial if they did not accept that some practices in the sector had got out of hand.

He said: "Where we’ve got it wrong we’ve got to be humble enough to say: ‘OK, we’ve got it wrong, let’s try and put it right.’

"We don’t even talk about conspiracies or political motivations, because if you go down that path you get completely sidetracked and you live in a bubble where you think everyone’s against you. I don’t believe that’s the case."

But his fellow panellist, David Mbaziira, head of external communications at the fundraising agency Home Fundraising, argued that much of the national coverage had been simply attacking charities.

"There have been isolated cases of bad practice, but specific cases were then expanded," he said.

"If you have a national media organisation in effect on a bit of a witch-hunt, looking at every aspect of what you do and how you do it, they’re going to find something."

Mbaziira argued that charities had been lumped together unfairly: "If we had a utility company and there was an issue, I don’t think we would then say that the entire commercial sector was at fault or using bad practice."

Peter Gilheany, director of PR at Forster Communications, pointed to the banking sector, where banks as a group had been criticised by the public after the 2008 crash.

The same thing had happened to charities, he said, partly because the sector had failed to explain to the public what it meant to be a modern charity.

Chloe Stables, external relations manager at the National Council for Voluntary Organisations, said the sector was in a better position to issue a coordinated respons, should another sector-wide scandal occur.

She said the NCVO, the Institute of Fundraising, the charity leaders group Acevo, the Charities Aid Foundation and others had increased the level of communication and information sharing between them.

"It isn’t helpful if there is a big story and we all come out and say different things," she said. "So it’s about making sure that the right hand knows what the left hand is doing."

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register
Already registered?
Sign in

More from Fundraising Week 2016…

The digital fundraising challenges for small charities

The digital fundraising challenges for small charities

Mandy Johnson, chief executive of Small Charities Coalition, offers her tips on charity storytelling

How to run an influencer campaign

How to run an influencer campaign

Get some top tips from the Dogs Trust's Jacqui Darlow

How technology is driving charities

How technology is driving charities

Vinay Nair, chief executive of the technology company Lightful, shares his views

Big Questions Live 2018

Big Questions Live 2018

Partner Content: Presented By JustGiving

It's easy to be pessimistic about the future of giving, with GDPR in effect and the potential impact of more sector scandals on donations, but is the outlook really so bleak or is it simply a case of finding new, engaging ways of reaching donors?

Watch: How crowdfunding can help charities

Watch: How crowdfunding can help charities

Jes Bailey of Crowdfund 360 shares her thoughts on how the fundraising method will develop

Watch: GDPR and its impact on fundraising

Watch: GDPR and its impact on fundraising

David Boorman from Bliss discusses fundraising once the regulation is introduced

Watch: The challenges for community fundraising

Watch: The challenges for community fundraising

Polly Rigby from Clic Sargent gives her views on the role of community fundraising, including the impact of the GDPR

Business Charity Awards: Corporate Foundation - Axis Foundation

Business Charity Awards: Corporate Foundation - Axis Foundation

For a corporate philanthropic foundation that has provided outstanding support to the charity sector

Business Charity Awards: Consortium - Tesco National Charity Partnership with Diabetes UK and the British Heart Foundation

Business Charity Awards: Consortium - Tesco National Charity Partnership with Diabetes UK and the British Heart Foundation

For an outstanding partnership between one or more companies and one or more UK charities

Business Charity Awards: Project of the Year - Prudential UK with Royal Voluntary Service for First Time for Everything

Business Charity Awards: Project of the Year - Prudential UK with Royal Voluntary Service for First Time for Everything

For a scheme or initiative, either in the UK or overseas, that has successfully worked with a UK charity to help its beneficiaries